CNN's Michael Smerconish: 'Not Every Question About Islam Is Islamophobic'

CNN's Michael Smerconish: 'Not Every Question About Islam Is Islamophobic'
Michael Smerconish. Photo: IVN News / CC BY 2.0

CNN host Michael Smerconish said Americans should be willing to confront hard questions about Islam and its relationship with Western values, arguing that raising such concerns should not automatically be dismissed as bigotry.

Smerconish raised the issue on Saturday's edition of his show during a discussion of immigration, religious freedom and assimilation in Western countries.

"There are hard questions that we need to confront," Smerconish said. "Not every question about Islam is Islamophobic."

Apostasy and Blasphemy Laws

Smerconish pointed to countries where governments enforce strict interpretations of Islamic law and impose severe penalties for conduct that is protected as individual liberty in the United States and other Western democracies.

READ MORE: CNN's Harry Enten Says Democrats Remain Underwater Despite Winning Congress: 'It Was Not a Vote for Them'

Those include laws criminalizing same-sex relationships, restrictions on women's rights, blasphemy statutes and penalties for leaving Islam. He specifically highlighted apostasy laws.

"There are countries in the world today where leaving Islam can be punishable by death," he said. "And I think Americans have a right to ask: How does that square with our values?"

Several Muslim-majority countries continue to criminalize consensual same-sex activity, and some maintain apostasy or blasphemy laws with severe penalties, although enforcement and legal standards differ substantially from nation to nation.

The U.S. Constitution protects both the free exercise of religion and the right of individuals to change their beliefs or practice no religion at all.

'Not a Monolithic Group'

At the same time, Smerconish emphasized that Islam encompasses a vast and diverse population and warned against treating the world's roughly 2 billion Muslims as a monolithic group.

He said the question is not whether Muslims should be allowed to practice their faith in America, which the First Amendment protects, but how societies should approach religious or ideological doctrines that conflict with liberal democratic principles.

READ MORE: Texas Gov.-Elect Gina Hinojosa Plans to Reverse Abbott's CAIR Terror Designation

His argument centered on whether a fear of appearing intolerant has made some Americans reluctant to discuss genuine conflicts between certain religious practices and Western ideas of individual rights.

He also drew a line between criticizing a religion and showing hostility toward its followers. Americans routinely debate doctrines within Christianity, Judaism and other faiths, he argued, and Islam should not be exempt from scrutiny simply because Muslims are a religious minority in the United States.

American Muslim organizations have repeatedly argued that extremists and authoritarian governments should not be treated as representative of Muslims generally, and civil liberties groups have warned that policy debates can cross into discrimination when people are judged solely on their faith.

Immigration and Assimilation

The discussion comes as immigration and assimilation remain major political issues after the midterm elections, with debates increasingly focused on whether newcomers should be expected to embrace principles such as religious liberty, equality before the law and free speech.

The issue has become especially contentious in Europe, where governments have struggled with debates over immigration, integration and the treatment of women and sexual minorities.

Smerconish argued that Americans should be able to defend Muslims against discrimination while still scrutinizing practices that appear incompatible with constitutional freedoms. "You can defend the rights of Muslims in America," he said, "and still ask difficult questions about what is happening in parts of the Muslim world."

Subscribe to Lib Fails

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe