DOJ Asks Appeals Court to Declare Alaska Senate Lawsuit Moot After Peltola Defeats Sullivan

DOJ Asks Appeals Court to Declare Alaska Senate Lawsuit Moot After Peltola Defeats Sullivan
Mary Peltola. Photo: Leah Herman, House Creative Services / Public domain

The Justice Department moved Thursday to effectively end its lawsuit seeking to delay certification of Alaska's Senate election, after Democrat Mary Peltola defeated Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in the final U.S. Senate race of the cycle to be called.

Federal attorneys told the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that the dispute had become moot because the election had already taken place and there was no practical way to determine whether voters had confused two candidates named Dan Sullivan.

"This Court should hold that this case is moot, vacate the underlying order, and remand for dismissal on that ground," Justice Department attorneys wrote.

The Second Dan Sullivan

The unusual lawsuit was filed before Election Day after a second candidate, retired teacher Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., qualified for the ballot alongside the incumbent Republican senator.

READ MORE: LAST BIG RACE CALLED – GOP LOSES ALASKA

The Justice Department argued that the similar names could confuse voters and potentially affect the outcome of a close election. President Donald Trump strongly supported the challenge and accused Democrats of recruiting the second Sullivan as a spoiler intended to siphon votes from the Republican incumbent.

The New York Times previously reported that Democratic operatives were involved in efforts to recruit Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. into the race. Peltola has denied knowing about or participating in any such effort, and the Alaska Supreme Court ruled before the election that he could legally remain on the ballot.

The Justice Department nevertheless sued Alaska, seeking to prevent officials from certifying a Peltola victory if the race was close enough that alleged voter confusion might have affected the result. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason rejected that request on Nov. 1, finding that the federal government lacked standing and questioning how officials could investigate individual voting decisions without violating ballot secrecy. The department appealed.

Margin Undercut the Case

Peltola ultimately won an outright majority, removing the need for additional rounds under Alaska's ranked-choice voting system. Her margin over the incumbent also exceeded the total number of votes received by Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., substantially weakening the government's argument that name confusion could have changed the outcome.

"The United States therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means of 'determin[ing] whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant to be cast for Senator Sullivan,'" Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward wrote.

The department is not simply asking the appeals court to affirm Gleason's ruling. Instead, it wants the 9th Circuit to vacate her decision and order the case dismissed as moot, which would erase the lower court's finding that the government lacked standing.

READ MORE: DOJ Moves to Preserve Alaska Ballots as Probe Into Second 'Dan Sullivan' Heats Up

"There is, accordingly, no need to delve into standing or the merits of the United States' claims," prosecutors wrote.

Criminal Probe Continues

Peltola welcomed the development. "For Alaskans, there is only one direction: forward," she said. "Now that the election is over and the voters sent a very clear message about the direction they want our state to go in, I'm eager to move forward and get to work on behalf of all Alaskans."

Alaska election officials are preparing to certify the results next week. But the end of the civil lawsuit does not necessarily conclude federal scrutiny of the controversy, as a separate criminal investigation into the recruitment of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. remains underway.

No criminal charges have been announced against Peltola, and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. has maintained that his candidacy was legitimate. The remaining question in the civil case is whether the appeals court will simply dismiss the dispute or also grant the department's request to wipe Gleason's ruling from the books.

Subscribe to Lib Fails

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe