Former Immigration Judge Says Ilhan Omar Could Face Citizenship Challenge if Fraud Is Proven

The federal investigation into Rep. Ilhan Omar could carry consequences that go well beyond a possible criminal case, according to a former immigration judge.

Nathan Hansen told Fox News that the Minnesota Democrat could face a challenge to her citizenship if investigators substantiate fraud allegations — particularly if any wrongdoing is tied to the process through which she became an American citizen.

To be clear, Hansen was describing possible legal outcomes. Prosecutors have not charged Omar, and no proceedings to revoke her citizenship have been filed.

Criminal Case vs. Denaturalization

Hansen stressed that a criminal conviction alone would not automatically strip a naturalized American of citizenship. Criminal penalties and naturalization proceedings involve different legal questions.

Instead, he said, the Justice Department could pursue a separate civil denaturalization proceeding, with officials exercising discretion over whether to bring one. A link between a criminal offense and the citizenship process, he suggested, would make such an action more likely.

Two Federal Inquiries

The report identifies two separate federal inquiries involving Omar: one into allegations concerning immigration records, and another into her financial disclosures, which reportedly show a dramatic change in reported assets over a single year. That financial probe, on its own, is not proof of any problem with her citizenship application.

The immigration inquiry reportedly examines whether Omar or her late father supplied fraudulent information during the naturalization process.

Homeland Security Investigations agents searched Omar's Washington residence on October 12 and reportedly seized her passport, cellphone and computer. Fox News later reported that investigators had also obtained Omar's DNA, though no lab findings have been described.

Sources familiar with the investigation have also alleged that Omar's real name is Ilhan Nur Said Elmi — a claim the report notes has not been independently established. Neither DNA collection nor an allegation about a name proves immigration fraud occurred.

For conservatives who want the law enforced consistently, the question is simple: does the evidence support the allegations under the laws that govern them? Hansen's assessment lays out a possible legal path, while leaving it to investigators to prove their case.

Who Is Nathan Hansen?

Hansen has practiced law for 23 years and served four months on the immigration bench earlier this year after being appointed by former Attorney General Pam Bondi.

He also addressed a key hurdle in prosecuting older conduct: statutes of limitations. Hansen argued that concealed fraud could affect those deadlines as a general legal principle. However, fraud does not automatically pause every criminal statute of limitations, and whether an old allegation could still be prosecuted depends on the specific offense and federal law. His comments don't establish that prosecutors could get past any particular deadline in Omar's case.

An Overwhelmed System

Hansen also raised broader concerns about how immigration courts are functioning, describing massive backlogs and asylum claims he considered questionable. He estimated that Minnesota has between 20,000 and 30,000 pending removal cases without scheduled court dates — his own estimate, not an official count.

The volume, he argued, shows a system that is overwhelmed and being used in ways it was never intended.

During his four months as a judge, Hansen said he encountered applications with inconsistent stories and documents he believed were fraudulent, Trending Politics reported. He described some claims as ones that "just totally didn't add up" and some supporting materials as "clearly fake."

If even part of that is true, the Omar investigation may be just one window into a much bigger problem.

Subscribe to Lib Fails

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe