Judge Boasberg — the Judge Trump Wanted Impeached — Takes Over Fight Over Ilhan Omar Search Warrant
Of all the federal judges in Washington, the fight over the search warrant in the Ilhan Omar investigation has landed in front of one Republicans know all too well.
Chief Judge James Boasberg, the Obama appointee who leads the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, is overseeing efforts to unseal the warrant used to search the Washington home of the Minnesota Democrat. President Trump has repeatedly criticized Boasberg and once called him a "Radical Left Lunatic."
Pirro: 'Rash'
U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro is urging the court to reject immediate disclosure while investigators finish executing the warrant.
"This request sounds rash because it is rash," Pirro wrote.
She asked the court to deny the request without prejudice, allowing it to be renewed once the warrant has been fully executed and a public charging decision has been made. That would let investigators complete their work before releasing material prosecutors believe could undermine the case.
The filing indicated the warrant's execution remained unfinished, even though agents conducted the physical search on October 12. Other details about the investigation and warrant records remain redacted.
Fox News Politics summed up the stakes on October 28, noting that the case lands on Boasberg's desk as two separate federal investigations into Omar are underway.
Who Wants the Warrant Unsealed
The New York Times, the conservative watchdog Judicial Watch and a coalition of 14 press organizations have all sought access to the warrant.
Boasberg initially ordered the Justice Department to defend continued sealing by October 22, then extended the deadline after the department asked to wait until the warrant was fully executed. The media organizations argue that sensitive details could be redacted without hiding the entire warrant, and they point out that the physical search took place weeks ago.
The dispute is about access to investigative documents — not a judicial finding that Omar committed any crime.
The Investigations
Homeland Security Investigations and the FBI searched Omar's residence under a warrant issued by Magistrate Judge Matthew Sharbaugh.
The warrant fight unfolds alongside federal scrutiny of Omar's immigration history and of discrepancies in her annual financial disclosures. Investigators are examining allegations that her father misstated her age on citizenship paperwork in 2000, which could have allowed Omar to obtain citizenship through him as a minor. Omar arrived in the United States from Somalia in 1995, at age 12.
President Trump has also repeated allegations about her marriage to Ahmed Nur Said Elmi and called for her to be jailed following the search.
Omar's attorneys, meanwhile, are demanding the return of seized property. They allege agents violated protections for her congressional work, failed to provide the warrant and prevented her from contacting her lawyers during the search.
Boasberg's Track Record
Boasberg's involvement draws attention because his past rulings have repeatedly put him at odds with President Trump and Republicans.
In March 2025, he temporarily blocked deportation flights carrying alleged Venezuelan gang members, prompting the President to call for his impeachment and accuse him of bias. In June 2025, he ordered agencies to preserve Signal messages in which senior officials discussed U.S. military strikes in Yemen, saying they could be federal records.
Boasberg also signed nondisclosure orders during the Arctic Frost investigation that kept phone carriers from notifying Republican lawmakers whose records had been subpoenaed. And he presided over the case of former FBI attorney Kevin Clinesmith, who pleaded guilty to altering an email used in surveillance applications targeting former Trump adviser Carter Page, Fox News reported.
None of that history determines how Boasberg will rule on access to the Omar records. But conservatives will be watching every move he makes.