Supreme Court Hands Trump Administration a Win, Refuses to Revive Biden-Era Immigration Rule
The Supreme Court on Tuesday handed President Donald Trump's administration a victory in the fight over immigration enforcement, refusing to bring back a Biden-era regulation that let immigration judges set aside certain deportation cases.
In a brief, unsigned order, the justices rejected an emergency request from three cities and an immigrant legal services group seeking to revive the rule. The decision leaves in place restrictions on the practice of temporarily suspending some deportation proceedings.
The applicants were Baltimore; Columbus, Ohio; New Haven, Connecticut; and Centro Legal de la Raza, according to court filings. They had asked the justices to suspend a lower-court judgment stemming from an agreement between Texas and the federal government.
The Supreme Court's docket shows that Justice Alito referred the application to the full court, which denied it October 27. No justice publicly noted a dissent, according to reporting on the order, which did not explain the court's reasoning. The denial keeps the existing judgment in effect but does not resolve every legal question underlying the case.
What Is Administrative Closure?
At the center of the dispute is administrative closure — a procedure that takes certain cases off active immigration court calendars without actually resolving them.
The Biden Justice Department adopted the disputed regulation in 2024 through the Executive Office for Immigration Review. It allowed immigration judges to pause proceedings while immigrants pursued humanitarian protections or other possible legal status through federal agencies.
Supporters argue that flexibility helps coordinate overlapping proceedings and prevents removal before another agency weighs available relief. Critics counter that lengthy administrative closures can keep cases from ever reaching a decision — undermining enforcement of the immigration laws Congress has passed. For those who believe in border security and the rule of law, that concern is central.
How Texas Won
Texas challenged the regulation, and the Trump administration agreed with the state that the rule went beyond lawful authority. The two sides jointly asked for a consent judgment declaring the regulations unlawful and blocking their enforcement.
The district court granted the request, vacated the 2024 rule and restricted substantially similar regulations absent an express basis in statute. For Republicans pushing for stronger immigration enforcement, Tuesday's order preserves that judgment while the challengers keep contesting their exclusion from the case.
The Fight Over Who Gets to Sue
The dispute involves not only the rule's validity but also whether the cities and legal organization can step in to defend it. According to the federal government's Supreme Court response, the applicants moved to intervene roughly six weeks after the judgment was entered.
The district court denied intervention, finding they had not shown the concrete injury required to appeal. The Fifth Circuit then declined to suspend the judgment or summarily reverse that decision, prompting the emergency application to the Supreme Court.
The cities argued that ending administrative closure could increase removals, reduce tax revenue and discourage cooperation with local police — including among immigrants who might qualify for protections tied to helping authorities investigate or prosecute crimes. Centro Legal argued that the changes would increase demands on its staff and require more legal resources.
The federal government disputed those claims, arguing that the alleged injuries depended on speculation rather than demonstrated, immediate harm, and that added workload alone does not give an organization standing. Those were the administration's arguments, not reasoning adopted in a written opinion by the court.
What the Order Does — and Doesn't — Do
The government also pointed to an important limit on the judgment: it applies going forward and does not require cases that were already closed to return to active calendars. That undercuts claims that Tuesday's order automatically reopened every suspended case or immediately ordered particular individuals deported.
The Supreme Court denied a request for temporary intervention; its action did not determine the immigration status of individual applicants, SCOTUS Blog reported.
The cities and the organization have also challenged how Texas and the administration obtained the judgment, arguing their agreement bypassed public rulemaking. For now, though, the Biden-era rule stays off the books — and the administration's enforcement agenda keeps moving forward.