Former Immigration Judge Says Ilhan Omar Could Face Citizenship Challenge If Fraud Is Proven

Former Immigration Judge Says Ilhan Omar Could Face Citizenship Challenge If Fraud Is Proven
Ilhan Omar. Photo: Kristie Boyd, U.S. House / Public domain

A former immigration judge says Minnesota Democratic Rep. Ilhan Omar could face a challenge to her U.S. citizenship if investigators substantiate fraud allegations against her.

Nathan Hansen made the comments to Fox News. He described potential legal outcomes, and prosecutors have not charged Omar or started any proceedings to revoke her citizenship.

Hansen emphasized that a criminal conviction alone would not automatically strip a naturalized American of citizenship, because criminal penalties and naturalization proceedings involve different legal questions.

A Separate Civil Proceeding

Hansen described possible Justice Department action through a separate civil proceeding and said officials would have discretion over whether to pursue it.

READ MORE: Judge Sets Hearing on Unsealing Records From Search of Ilhan Omar's Home

He suggested that a connection between a criminal offense and the citizenship process could make a denaturalization case more likely.

Hansen has practiced law for 23 years and served four months on the immigration bench earlier this year. He was appointed by former Attorney General Pam Bondi.

He also addressed whether statutes of limitations could prevent charges over older conduct, offering the view that concealed fraud could affect those deadlines. Whether an older allegation could support prosecution, however, depends on the specific offense and federal law. That matters because claims about an earlier naturalization process may involve events that occurred many years ago.

Hansen also raised broader concerns about immigration court operations, describing significant backlogs and asylum applications he considered questionable.

Two Federal Inquiries

The report identifies two separate federal inquiries involving Omar. One concerns allegations about immigration records, and the other involves questions about her financial disclosures, including a dramatic change in her reported assets over one year.

The immigration inquiry reportedly examines whether fraudulent information was supplied during the naturalization process by Omar or her late father.

READ MORE: Forensic Expert Says Epstein's Injuries Point to Homicide, Not Suicide

Federal agents searched Omar's Washington residence on Oct. 12 and reportedly seized her passport, cellphone and computer. Homeland Security Investigations, the Department of Homeland Security's investigative arm, conducted the search.

Fox News later reported that investigators had also obtained Omar's DNA, although no resulting laboratory findings have been described. Sources familiar with the investigation have also alleged that Omar's actual name is Ilhan Nur Said Elmi, a claim that has not been independently established.

Court Fight Over Sealed Records

Hansen's comments come as Chief Judge James E. Boasberg scheduled a hearing for Tuesday, Nov. 17, at 11 a.m. in federal court in Washington, D.C., on whether the public can see records behind the search of Omar's home.

"The Government shall be prepared to address why materials beyond the Affidavit itself cannot be unsealed," Boasberg wrote in his Nov. 12 order.

Fourteen press organizations and the conservative watchdog Judicial Watch are asking the court to unseal the warrant, the application and the affidavits supporting it. Judicial Watch filed its request on Oct. 15, three days after the search, arguing the public has a right to see the records under both common law and the First Amendment.

The group also requested any return and inventory, which could show how the warrant was executed and what agents reported taking from the home, along with the docket sheet and related motions, orders and transcripts.

Judicial Watch said Omar disputed the government's account and used the search and related comments to solicit campaign contributions.

Subscribe to Lib Fails

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe