Minnesota Prosecutor Charges James O'Keefe and Cam Higby After Undercover Election Sting
Expose a weakness in Minnesota's election system, and Hennepin County's left-wing prosecutor will come after you. That appears to be the lesson from Wednesday's charges against two well-known conservative investigators.
Investigative journalist James O'Keefe and political commentator Cam Higby have been charged with felonies in Minnesota over an undercover operation they say was designed to reveal vulnerabilities in the state's election system. The case sets up a legal fight over whether what they did was journalism or crossed a line into unlawful voting activity.
Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty announced that O'Keefe, 42, and Higby, 26, each face felony counts of unlawful voting and identity theft stemming from videos recorded during Minnesota's August 11 primary.
What Prosecutors Allege
Prosecutors say the two men visited several Hennepin County polling places and gave election judges the names of real registered voters, without those voters' knowledge or permission, while testing Minnesota's same-day registration and voter-vouching procedures.
Neither man actually cast a ballot, and prosecutors concede they stopped before signing the voter oath required to complete the process.
Moriarty argues that doesn't matter, because Minnesota law bars intentionally misrepresenting someone's identity not just while voting but while applying for a ballot.
"They did begin to apply," Moriarty said, contending that falsely identifying oneself to an election judge is part of the ballot-application process even if no vote is cast.
O'Keefe and Higby say they were conducting an undercover journalistic investigation to see how far election officials would let them go before demanding more verification. Both are scheduled to make their first court appearances on November 16.
The Burqa Video
Higby's video went viral in August. "I wore a burqa to a Minneapolis polling station and the poll worker was going to allow me to VOTE IN A WOMAN'S NAME," he posted on August 14, adding that the worker was also going to let him vouch for another unregistered person.
The videos zeroed in on Minnesota's decades-old "vouching" system, which allows a registered voter in a precinct to attest that another eligible voter lives at a particular address as one way of proving residence for Election Day registration. A registered voter can vouch for up to eight people, though applicants must also verify their identities and vouchers must sign an oath under penalty of perjury.
O'Keefe's organization said the team deliberately presented poll workers with an extreme scenario to test what safeguards they would require and how far the registration process could go. The footage showed the activists in disguises, using false names and addresses belonging to registered Minnesota voters and asking officials about registration procedures.
Prosecutors say election workers grew suspicious and reported the activity, which eventually led to an investigation.
Democrats Cheer the Charges
Democratic Minnesota Secretary of State Steve Simon praised authorities for pursuing the case, saying attempts to deceive election workers would not be tolerated. He has previously called the videos heavily edited and accused the activists of trying to undermine confidence in Minnesota elections rather than uncovering real fraud.
O'Keefe and Higby reject that, saying their whole purpose was to find out whether Minnesota's rules could be exploited by someone willing to lie.
"This investigation was conducted to expose vulnerabilities in the Minnesota voting system, which affects all Americans," Higby said after the charges were announced.
"I never voted, I never signed an affidavit, and I never violated a law," he added, arguing that prosecutors want to punish him for exposing weaknesses in the system.
O'Keefe has likewise framed the prosecution as an attack on investigative journalism and free speech. Prosecutors, meanwhile, insist journalistic intent provides no legal immunity for conduct barred by election and identity-theft laws.
What They Face
Each man faces one count of identity theft and one count of unlawful voting. Each felony carries a maximum of five years in prison and a $10,000 fine, though Moriarty said the offenses would likely carry presumptive probation under Minnesota sentencing guidelines if they were convicted.
Moriarty denied that her office brought the case to send a political message, saying election officials responded to specific conduct they believed broke state law.
The defendants see it differently: their videos, they say, showed poll workers letting the process move much further than it should have for people presenting themselves under identities that weren't their own. If that's true, the real scandal isn't the sting — it's the system it exposed.