Federal Judge Blocks Connecticut From Enforcing Mask, ID and Use-of-Force Rules Against ICE Agents
A federal judge on Friday blocked Connecticut from enforcing several of its new restrictions against Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents and other federal personnel, dealing a setback to the state's effort to regulate federal immigration enforcement.
U.S. District Judge Vernon D. Oliver, a Biden appointee, issued a preliminary injunction covering portions of the state's rules on use of force, face coverings and identification.
The order applies to federal officers, agents and employees. The provisions remain enforceable against state and local officers.
Supremacy Clause
At the center of the ruling is the Constitution's Supremacy Clause, which limits state interference with federal operations. Oliver concluded that the challenged provisions likely violate that protection by regulating federal officers performing federal duties.
He also found that threatened enforcement could interfere with federal operations and create safety risks for officers and their families.
What Connecticut Tried to Impose
Connecticut's use-of-force provisions set standards and direct state officials to investigate conduct falling outside those rules. In certain circumstances, they also direct officials to prosecute uses of force considered unjustified.
Other requirements generally prohibit officers from wearing face coverings during public interactions, subject to exceptions. The identification provisions generally require officers to display a badge and name tag during planned arrests or public interactions.
Despite those exceptions, the court found sufficient grounds to block the rules from being applied to federal personnel while the case proceeds.
The injunction does not erase the provisions from state law, and it does not extend the same protection to state and local officers. The ruling concerns Connecticut's authority over federal operations rather than every application of its policing requirements.
Under the order, the state, Gov. Ned Lamont and Chief State's Attorney Patrick Griffin cannot enforce the covered restrictions against federal personnel. Inspector General Eliot Prescott is separately barred from enforcing several sections addressing use of force.
Attorney General William Tong was dismissed from the case after the court found he lacked authority to enforce the challenged provisions. His dismissal reflects that enforcement question rather than any finding that the restrictions are constitutional.
No Blanket Immunity
The judge also stressed that federal employment does not automatically provide blanket immunity from state prosecution. Immunity depends on whether officers acted within their federal authority and did no more than was necessary and proper, he found.
That leaves room to scrutinize conduct that falls outside protected federal duties, WFSB reported. The ruling blocks particular state restrictions without declaring that every action by a federal officer is beyond review.
Still, the court's reasoning places federal authority ahead of state efforts to dictate how federal officers carry out their assigned work. At the same time, the order does not turn federal authority into unrestricted permission to use force.
Because the order is preliminary, the constitutional dispute is not over. The judge found that the provisions likely violate the Supremacy Clause but did not issue a final judgment, CT Insider reported.
For now, ICE personnel in Connecticut are protected from enforcement of the covered requirements while the litigation continues, and the state cannot impose the blocked rules on federal officers.