Wisconsin Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Against Elon Musk Over $1 Million Checks in 2025 Supreme Court Race
A Wisconsin judge has thrown out a lawsuit against Elon Musk and his America PAC over payments tied to the state's 2025 Supreme Court election, ruling that the challengers had not shown a concrete injury.
Brown County Circuit Judge Marc Hammer dismissed the case against Musk, America PAC and United States of America Inc. He signed the decision on Nov. 18, and it was filed on Nov. 19, the same day defense attorneys filed notice of entry of the final order.
The plaintiffs were the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign, Paul Gagliardi and Deborah Patel. They sought declarations on two election bribery counts and one unlawful lottery count, and also pursued civil conspiracy and public nuisance claims in the name of Wisconsin.
They asked for damages and an order barring the defendants from similar conduct in future elections.
READ MORE: Inside the Ballot Fight the Supreme Court Shut Down in One Sentence on the Eve of the Midterms
No Concrete Injury
The defendants offered five grounds for dismissal, but Hammer focused on whether the plaintiffs had standing to sue. He found that they had not alleged that the defendants prevented them from voting, burdened their ability to cast ballots or otherwise affected their own voting.
The broader claim that the defendants undermined Wisconsin's democracy did not satisfy the requirement for a concrete injury, the judge found.
Hammer also rejected arguments based on the time and money the plaintiffs spent opposing the defendants, explaining that voluntary political advocacy and campaign contributions do not become imposed losses simply because opponents provoke a response.
"Mere disagreement or frustration with Defendants' conduct is insufficient to confer standing," Hammer wrote.
The ruling addressed only who could bring the lawsuit. It did not decide whether the disputed payments were lawful.
The Petition and the Checks
According to the decision, America PAC posted a petition opposing activist judges on March 20, 2025, offering registered Wisconsin voters $100 for signing and another $100 for each successful referral. The offer expired at the end of Election Day, April 1, 2025.
READ MORE: DOJ Asks Appeals Court to Declare Alaska Senate Lawsuit Moot After Peltola Defeats Sullivan
On March 27, Musk announced an upcoming Wisconsin appearance. According to the decision, his initial post referred to two million-dollar checks offered in appreciation for taking time to vote. Musk deleted that announcement and posted another limiting admission to people who had signed the petition.
At the March 30 event in Green Bay, Musk brought two attendees on stage and gave each a $1 million check. The plaintiffs argued the arrangement was an effort to exchange money for participation in a civic duty and constitutional right.
No Criminal Charges Either
The civil dismissal follows an earlier decision not to pursue criminal charges. The Wisconsin Elections Commission voted 5-1 to refer possible bribery violations to the Brown County district attorney, whose office sought a special prosecutor.
In August, La Crosse County District Attorney Tim Gruenke announced he would not charge Musk, saying he did not believe he could obtain a conviction. "Nobody was paid anything of value for voting or promising to vote," Gruenke wrote, WBAY reported.
The criminal charging decision and Hammer's civil ruling addressed different legal questions, but both ended without any penalty against Musk. Those allegations formed the core of the complaint, yet they never got past the court's standing analysis.